peach shrub

peach shrub // brooklyn supperOnce, I was a martini kind of girl. Waiting for a table at a cool restaurant, it was no big deal to toss one back. And though I do like the things, there was more than a hint of bravado in my order––obviously, I was pretty tough.

After martinis, I moved on to whiskey on the rocks. I tried ordering whiskey with ice a lot, because “rocks” felt a little silly, or maybe not up to par with my otherwise tough lady sip, but then I realized I was just being a pain in the ass for bartenders, who always misunderstood ice and really just wanted me to say rocks. So there I was, whiskey on the rocks.

peach shrub // brooklyn supper

Between babies and the craft cocktail revolution, my cocktail consumption ebbed. I do enjoy a fine cocktail, but not being among the initiated, I feel silly sitting somewhere fancy and asking the poor barkeep to define and explain each element in a complex comestible. There’s pressure, too. To order whiskey on the rocks in a cocktail temple would be wrong. So I gravitate toward the simple. Something strong, bitter, and bright for sure, but more than four elements leave me feeling a bit lost.

With this in mind, I’ve decided this is the year to reclaim the cocktail. I mix up batches of herbed simple syrups, smash some fruit, toss in bitters or a splash of lemon, and that’s plenty for me. I write all this in the hopes that you too will reclaim cocktails. Let’s rise up and wrest control from the hands of baroque mixologists everywhere!

peach shrub // brooklyn supper

peach shrub // brooklyn supperAnd if you were looking for opposite of a schmancy cocktail, and you wanted something simple and down-home and good, surely then you would want a shrub. Shrubs vary wildly, but at their essence, they are a vinegar-based simple syrup infused with fruit. Techniques and ratios are all over the place, but for mine I went with one part sugar, one part apple cider vinegar, to two parts chopped peaches. I placed the peaches and the sugar together in a large jar and let them mingle for a day or two, I then added the vinegar, and left things for another four or so days.

The final mixture is suffused with peach fragrance, and the flavor has all the bright, faintly buttery fruit undertones you’d expect, not to mention the pleasant sourness of vinegar. My shrub was served with one part shrub, one part vodka, and two parts soda. Our guests were smitten, and so were we. Shrubs for all!

peach shrub // brooklyn supper
peach shrub // brooklyn supper
One last note on this terribly lengthy post, my shrub was inspired by Brian from A Thought for Food and The Boys Club. He demonstrated his technique at the Big Summer Potluck, and spread shrub mania like wildfire. The Big Summer Potluck is so special to me, and I was incredibly thankful to be there again this year. I can’t tell you how refreshing it was to spend a weekend surrounded by so many familiar friendly faces.

And don’t forget to swing by and enter our Great Midwest cheese giveaway! Contest runs through August 19.

Peach Shrub (adapted from Michael Dietsch via Serious Eats and A Thought for Food)

makes about a quart and a half

This recipe is an ideal way to use up nearly expired fruit.

6 cups peaches, pitted and chopped
3 cups granulated sugar
3 cups apple cider vinegar

In a large jar or other vessel with a tight-fitting lid, combine the chopped peaches and sugar. Use the back of a wooden spoon or a muddler to smash the fruit a bit. Cover and refrigerate.

After a day or two––once all of the sugar has dissolved––add the vinegar. Swirl a bit, cover, and set back in the fridge. After 4 or 5 days, or up to a week, taste the mixture. If it’s to your liking, that is, fruity with mellow vinegar flavor, strain out the fruit with a mesh sieve and pour the syrup into clean jars.

Your shrub should keep well, covered in the fridge, for three weeks.

Peach Shrub Collins (adapted from A Thought for Food)
makes one cocktail

1 1/2 ounces peach shrub
1 1/2 ounces vodka (we used Tito’s)
3 ounces seltzer
Peach slices for garnish

Pour the shrub and the vodka over ice. Add the peach slices and seltzer, stir gently, serve.


  1. says

    I love this lookback! I, too, have moved away from cocktails, but in the last few months, have started to get inspired and intrigued by the more ingredient-driven libations. Making shrub has been high on my summer to-do list (which I’m terribly behind on). I am going to have to try this before all the peaches are gone! xo

  2. says

    I feel like everyone has been drinking shrubs without me and this is certain proof. There’s so many things I love about them in concept, so maybe I need to run with your recipe a bit. Also, I am phasing out of my gin martini phase and BACK into bourbon on the rocks (but preferably on ice, seriously) out of a need for some simplicity too. Pour-overs and basic tipples are way more appealing nowadays. I love, love, love the colour mix in that last photo too.

  3. says

    I’ve been enjoying the use of shrubs for a couple of years; they are not new but they are certainly enjoying a comeback. At one time simply a way to preserve some of summers harvest during the winter; I love them like you do in a simple cocktail. SO many options opened up with different fruits and different vinegars!

    Peaches in Colorado are at their very best; this is an inspiration of just one more way to use their bounty. As my daughter would say? Nummers!

  4. Christian Harrison says

    The peaches I have are pretty fuzzy. Do you blanch and skin your peaches? Or strain everything through a fine cloth?

    • Elizabeth says

      Hi Christian, After the shrub has co-mingled for a while, you’ll want to strain all of the fruit, skins and all, so that you’re left with a sugary syrup. For extra fuzzy peaches, I just give them a good rinse and rub off some of the fuzz under the running water. Enjoy!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>